The first Azarov government (Ukrainian: Перший уряд Миколи Азарова, Russian: Первое правительство Николая Азарова) was Ukraine's cabinet from its appointment on March 11, 2010 until its dissolution on December 3, 2012. It continued to serve as a caretaker government[1] until 24 December 2012, when the second Azarov government was appointed by presidentViktor Yanukovych.[2]
A November 2010 Razumkov Centre nationwide survey showed that only 13.2 percent of respondents fully supported the Azarov Government while 45 percent stated they did not.[3]
Its composition was reshuffled by Yanukovych early in 2012.[4]
Creation and parliamentary issues
Termination
On December 3, 2012, the government became a caretaker government after Ukrainian presidentViktor Yanukovich accepted the resignation of prime minister Mykola Azarov and his government following the 28 October 2012 parliamentary election.[1] A number of government members, including Prime Minister Azarov, were elected to parliament in that election.[1] In order to get these parliamentary mandates they were obliged to submit documents on the dismissal from their previous job to the Central Election Commission within 20 days after the election (by December 3).[5]
On 9 December 2012, Yanukovych nominated Azarov for a new term as prime minister.[6] This nomination was approved by parliament on 13 December 2012.[7] On 24 December 2012, the second Azarov government was appointed by President Yanukovych.[2]
In January 2013, President Yanukovych stated the government "has not completely fulfilled the assigned tasks on ensuring the introduction of reform and economic growth. This led to the fact that the results in 2012 were much worse than expected".[8]
Controversy and criticism
Azarov's immediate predecessor Yulia Tymoshenko stated on the day the cabinet was elected "this government is completely made up of Ukrainian oligarchs"; she predicted the cabinet actions would lead to "megacorruption, the closure of strategic state programs, pressure on small and middle business and a return to stagnation and the absence of any reforms".[9]
According to a February 2010 poll by the Kyiv Gorshenin Institute of Management Issues most Ukrainians wanted not a politician for prime minister but "a professional premier, who will implement unpopular reforms".[10]
Ukraine's state budget for 2010 was adopted by parliament after a ten-minute-long hearing of the bill which consisted of a report by the finance minister and the head of the parliament's budget committee.[11] The Verkhovna Rada 2010 budget was not presented at a parliament meeting, but approved on May 14, 2010.[12][13]
Constitutional Court ruling
According to former president Victor Yushchenko the March 9, 2010 parliamentary amendment that made it possible for individual members of a parliamentary faction to join a coalition violated the Ukrainian Constitution,[14] former Minister of Internal AffairsYuriy Lutsenko accused Yanukovych of "trying to buy members of parliament for a new coalition"[15] (PresidentViktor Yanukovych accused Lutsenko of badly handling the affairs at the Ministry of Internal Affairs before appointing Anatolii Mohyliov to Lutsenko's old position.[16]) and Yulia Tymoshenko Bloc lawmaker Serhiy Mishchenko stated "that the Verkhovna Rada had shown to the average citizen a bad example of how to violate the country's laws and Constitution".[17] Yushchenko did send a letter to Yanukovych with a request to veto the law on March 10.[18] Yanukovych signed the law nevertheless.[19] 56 lawmakers filed a challenge to the law who made these amendments possible on March 11, 2010, at the Constitutional Court of Ukraine.[19][20] On March 16, 2010, Minister of Justice Oleksandr Lavrynovych stated that even if the Constitutional Court rules the amendments unconstitutional the format of the Ukrainian parliamentary coalition will remain unchanged because "the Constitutional Court's ruling becomes valid on the day of its announcement, not yesterday or the day before yesterday" and the Constitutional Court's ruling will apply only to measures intended to establish a new coalition in Ukraine in the future.[21] On March 26, 2010, President Yanukovych told a delegation from the European Parliament "If the decision of the Constitutional Court will be that the coalition was formed illegally, then I will take a decision on a snap election, I will never go down the path of breaching the constitution that is in force".[22] The Constitutional Court reviewing the case late March 2010.[22] On urgent matters the court rules within weeks but on matters deemed less urgent it can take months or even longer.[22] On March 29, 2010, former premier and Yulia Tymoshenko Bloc leader Yulia Tymoshenko accused "Representatives of Yanukovych" of trying to bribe and blackmail Constitutional Court judges in order to get a ruling that legitimates the coalition and the government.[23] This was denied by Yanukovych's Party of Regions.[24]
On April 8, 2010, the Constitutional Court ruled that the coalition supporting the Azarov government in parliament had been formed legally.[25] The shadow government called the Constitutional Court ruling "cynical, hypocritical, and illegal".[26]
Corruption
The Azarov government stated that it will fight corruption. However several of its members are assigned to two or more government positions, and, of course, are paid for them.[citation needed] That fact reflects direct disregard for the Constitution of Ukraine. Some of the members do not even qualify to the assigned positions either as in case with Valeriy Khoroshkovskiy who was elected to the Supreme Council of Justice.[27] Some of the members of the government received their government assignments without a basic knowledge of the state language as in case with the Minister of Internal Affairs Mohyliov.[28] The President Yanukovych gave him two months (until August 2010) to learn the language.
Opposition government formation
On March 16, eight parliamentarian parties signed an application for the establishment of an association of opposing political forces to the ruling Azarov government.[29] Among the eight opposition parties are All-Ukrainian Union "Fatherland", Rukh, European Party of Ukraine, People's Self-Defense, Reforms and Order Party, Motherland Defenders Party, Christian-Democratic Union, and Ukrainian Social-Democratic Party. Tymoshenko immediately nominated a prime minister for the future opposition government (so called shadow government), while the leader of the European Party Mykola Katerynchuk suggests not to rush and consolidate all possible political forces in a single formed opposition government.[30] On March 31, 2010, all members of this government were named.[31] It is headed by parliamentarian Serhiy Sobolev of Bloc of Yulia Tymoshenko.[31] Its vice premier, Volodymyr Stretovych, was dismissed on 7 February 2011, because "he had finally taken the side of the government".[32]
Arseniy Yatsenyuk formed another oppositional government in March 2010.[33]
On March 11, 2010, Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine approved the structure of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine.[37] Note, Tihipko even though is a leader of the Strong Ukraine party, he was elected to Cabinet as unaffiliated. Strong Ukraine in Verkhovna Rada is not an independent party. The same goes with Vasyl Tsushko who was a former member of the Socialist Party of Ukraine at the time of his appointment (he became the leader of that party in July 2010[38]); Tsushko was appointed on quote of the Communist Party.[39]
The Cabinet originally consisted of 29 ministers, four more than the previous government,[40] but has since been trimmed down.[41][42][43] At the time of installation the Cabinet contained the highest number of ministers in Europe, and ranked second in Europe in terms of the number of its vice premiers.[44][45] 8 out of the original 29 Cabinet members were born in Donetsk and the Donetsk Oblast.[46]
The Cabinet was (also at the time of its installation) Europe's only government that has no female members in its composition till Raisa Bohatyryova was appointed Minister of Healthcare and Vice Prime Minister of Ukraine on 14 February 2012.[44][47] It was the first Ukrainian government without a female minister.[48]
As of May 21, 2010, the Cabinet stated it was planning to create a "Ministry of Science, Technologies and Innovation of Ukraine".[49]
Changes since June 2010
On June 2, 2010, deputy-minister of Environmental Protection Bogdan Presner was sacked for accepting a bribe of $200,000[54] (he was sentenced to nine years in prison in October 2011[55]). On June 17, 2010, Minister on Communal Living Oleksandr Popov (Party of Regions) was replaced by Yuriy Hivrich.[56][57]
On July 2, 2010, Minister of Environmental Protection Viktor Boyko (Bloc Lytvyn) was replaced by Mykola Zlochevskiy[58][59][60] and Vice Prime Minister Volodymyr Seminozhenko was fired by the Verkhovna Rada (Ukrainian parliament) the same day.[41] A draft resolution proposing the dismissal of Semynozhenko was submitted by lawmaker Olha Bodnar of Bloc Yulia Tymoshenko.[41] On July 10, 2010, Minister of Extraordinary Situations Nestor Shufrych was dismissed by Verkhovna Rada.[61] For his dismissal voted 256 deputies. However Viktor Yanukovych found a new assignment for Shufrych and appointed him as the assistant to the secretary of the Council for National Security.[62] Shufrych's duties were temporary assigned to Volodymyr Antonets[63] till Mikhail Bolotskikh was appointed acting minister on July 23, 2010.[64] Soon after the motion to overturn the 2004 Constitutional amendments was filed on July 14 by the representatives of the Azarov Government, Vasyl Tsushko, previously as an unaffiliated member of the government, was elected the leader of the Socialist Party of Ukraine (extra parliamentarian party, non-coalition) on July 24, 2010.
On October 13, 2010, President Yanukovych sacked two deputy prime ministers (Viktor Slauta and Volodymyr Sivkovich).[65] The sackings were the first case when Yanukovych used the powers granted to him by this month's constitutional court ruling when 2004 constitutional amendments were overturned.[65]
On November 12, 2010, President Yanukovych appointed Viktor Baloha (United Centre) Minister of Emergencies and Minister of the Protection of the Population from the Chernobyl disaster.[66] According to Baloha this did not mean his party would join the coalition.[67] Early 2010 United Centre had rejected any possibility of joining a parliamentary coalition with the Communist Party of Ukraine.[68][69]
Another mayor reshuffle took place in December 2010, which reduced the number of ministers[43][70] This was part of an administrative reform set in motion by Ukrainian presidentViktor Yanukovych with the aim to reduce the number of civil servants in Ukraine.[42][71] (see below Yanukovych Administration Reform)
A number of deputy ministers were dismissed early April 2011.[72]
Minister of Health Zynoviy Mytnyk was dismissed on May 17, 2011, because he had "failed to properly organize the work of the ministry"; Oleksandr Anishchenko was appointed for the post on May 24, 2010.[73][74]
On 22 February 2012, Khoroshkovsky was reshuffled to First Vice Prime Minister-Minister and dismissed as finance minister[51]Yuriy Kolobov was appointed finance minister on 28 February 2012.[81] On 9 March 2012 President Yanukovych stated he wanted Petro Poroshenko to work in the government on the post of economic development and trade minister.[82] Poroshenko was appointed economic development and trade minister of Ukraine by Yanukovych on 23 March 2012.[83]
Reducing the gap between the rich and the poor in Ukraine;[88] which is characterized by these policies:
Raise the minimum wage in 2010 to 888 Hryvnya.[89]
In April 2012 Prime Minister Azarov stated that the Azarov Government was planning to increase pensions and wages four times in 2013 - once every quarter - and to increase social benefits twice.[90]
Improve the living standards of Ukrainians;[91] which is characterized by these policies:
Creating a state "anti-crisis food basket" and a "state anti-crisis medical basket";[91]
Stabilization of the price situation on the consumer market and the energy market.[92]
Introduce "the European standards of social protection" in Ukraine;[91] which is characterized by these policies:
Reform of the system of social standards and privileges;[91]
Improvement of the social protection of children;[91]
"Fight" against the demographic crisis.[91]
Reviewing Ukraine's cooperation with international financial organizations;[93]
Improving the financial situation in state companies;[94]
Reform the housing utility sector;[92][94] which is characterized by these policies:
Provision of citizens with affordable housing;[91]
The formation of a state order for the construction of social housing for young people, public sector employees, poor families, and disabled persons.[91]
Ensuring the rights and freedoms of citizens in Ukraine and their protection outside the country.[96]
Other priorities of the government are the preparations for expected flooding, preparations for spring agricultural work and the improvement of medical services.[92]
In order to increase state revenues with at least Hryvnya 10 billion the government is planning to step up privatization in 2010.[97]
Led by the Party of Regions faction in March 2010 a draft law on the judiciary and a new criminal procedural code was shelved and the introduction of anti-corruption legislation was pushed back from April 2010 to January 2011 by the Verkhovna Rada.[98]
On November 30, 2010, Yanukovych vetoed a new tax code made by the Azarov Government and earlier approved by the Verkhovna Rada but protested against in rallies across Ukraine (one of the largest protests since the 2004 Orange Revolution).[99][100][101] Yanukovych signed a new Tax Code on December 3, 2010.[102]
in an (Ukraine's) economy analysis of March 2014 The Economist claims that poor economic policies by the Azarov Government had weakened the state's finances.[103]
Yanukovych Administration Reform
On December 9, 2010, the President of Ukraine reloaded a new government.[104] According to the decree, the number of ministries was reduced from 20 to 16 and the number of cabinet employees (1,174 people at the time) is to be more than halved.[105]
List of ministries with their respective agencies (if present)
Ministry of Economy is reorganized into Ministry of Economic Development and Trade (coordinated by the First Deputy Premier)
State Service of Export Control
State Committee of Statistics reorganized into State Service of Statistics
State Service of Technical Regulation
National Agency in ensuring of energy resources effective use reorganized into State Agency of Energy Effectiveness and Savings
State Agency in directing national projection and State Agency of investments and development merged into State Agency of investments and directing national projects
State Committee of state material reserves reorganized into State Agency of Reserves
Ministry of Industrial Policy reorganized into State Agency in directing state corporation rights and property
Ministry of Transportation and Communications reorganized into Ministry of Infrastructure with several state services (coordinated by a Deputy Premier)
State Aviation Service
State Automobile-Transportation Service
State Service of Communication
State Service of Sea and River Transportation
State Service of Automobile Roads
National Agency in preparation and conduction the final portion of Euro 2012 championship of football in Ukraine and realization of infrastructural projects
Ministry of Regional Development and Construction and Ministry of Communal Living merge into Ministry of Regional Development, Construction, and Communal Living (coordinated by a Deputy Premier)
State Architectural-Building Inspection
Ministry of Labor and Social Policy reorganized into Ministry of Social Policy and State Inspection in labor affairs (coordinated by a Deputy Premier)
State Inspection in Labor Affairs
State Committee in Veteran Affairs reorganized into State Service in affairs of handicapped and veterans
Pension Fund
Ministry of Agrarian Policy reorganized into Ministry of Agrarian Policy and Food
State inspection of rural management
State Committee of Veterinary Medicine reorganized into State Veterinary Services
State Committee of land resources reorganized into State Agency of land resources
State Committee of forest management reorganized into State Agency of forest resources
State Committee of fishing management reorganized into State Agency of fishing management
Ministry of Internal Affairs
State Migration Service
Ministry in protection of nature reorganized into Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Economy reorganized into Ministry of Economical Development and Trade, under the responsibility of the First Vice Prime Minister (December 9, 2010 - February 14, 2012)
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Culture and Tourism reorganized into Ministry of Culture
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Fuel and Energy reorganized into Ministry of Energy [Generation] and Coal [Mining]
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry on Issues of Emergencies and Population Security from consequences of Chornobyl Catastrophe reorganized into Ministry of Emergencies
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Regional Development and Construction reorganized into Ministry of Regional Development, Construction and Communal Living
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Communal Living reorganized into Ministry of Regional Development, Construction and Communal Living
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Transportation and Communication reorganized into Ministry of Infrastructure
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Labor and Social Policy reorganized into Ministry of Social Policy
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Industrial Policy reorganized into Ministry of Economical Development and Trade
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Coal Industry reorganized into Ministry of Energy [Generation] and Coal [Mining]
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Family, Youth and Sports merged into Ministry of Education and Sciences
^On December 9, 2010 Ministry of Cabinet of Ministers lost its ministerial portfolio
References
^ a b cYanukovych dismisses Azarov and Cabinet of Ministers, Kyiv Post (3 December 2012) Ukraine government resigns, stays on in acting role, Kyiv Post (3 December 2012)
^Yushchenko: Decision to sanction coalition based on individual lawmakers unconstitutional, Kyiv Post (March 9, 2010)
^Lutsenko: Yanukovych team trying to 'buy members of parliament' for new coalition, Kyiv Post (March 9, 2010)
^President presented a new staff to their departments Podrobnosti.ua March 11, 2010 (video-footage)(in Russian)
^Serhiy Mishchenko: parliament showed the public how to break laws Archived 2011-07-16 at the Wayback Machine, Official website of Yulia Tymoshenko (March 10, 2010)
^Yushchenko calls for Yanukovych to veto amendments to law on parliament's regulations, Kyiv Post (March 10, 2010)
^ a bUkraine opposition challenges Yanukovych in court, Kyiv Post (March 12, 2010)
^Constitutional Court gets motion on constitutionality of parliament's rules of procedure, Kyiv Post (March 12, 2010)
^Minister: Newly formed Ukrainian coalition will remain unchanged, Kyiv Post (March 16, 2010)
^ a b cYanukovych to call vote if coalition ruled illegal, Kyiv Post (March 1, 2010)
^Tymoshenko: Yanukovych entourage aims at recognizing legitimacy of coalition before president's trip to U.S., Kyiv Post (March 29, 2010)
^Yanukovych allies: Tymoshenko trying to pressure court, Kyiv Post (March 30, 2010)
^(in Ukrainian) Оробець: При формуванні нової парламентської коаліції «фактор комуністів» і Конституція несумісні, Official party website (March 9, 2010)
^(in Russian) Балога: Мы много помогали на выборах Януковичу и не скрываем этого, Official party website (March 9, 2010)
^Yanukovych appoints Mohyliov to Crimean post, Kyiv Post (7 November 2011)
^Chief tax officer Zakharchenko appointed interior minister of Ukraine, Kyiv Post (7 November 2011)
^Yanukovych dismisses Khoroshkovsky from military service, Kyiv Post (19 January 2012)
^Ukraine gets new defence minister, Kyiv Post (8 February 2012)
^"President presents newly appointed NSDC Secretary" (Press release). Administration of President. 2012-02-14. Retrieved 2012-02-15.
^"Ukrainian president replaces National Security and Defense Council secretary". Interfax. 2012-02-14. Retrieved 2012-02-15.
^Yanukovych appoints Kolobov as finance minister, Kyiv Post (28 February 2012)
^Ukrainian president wants Poroshenko to head economic development and trade ministry, Kyiv Post (9 March 2012)
^Poroshenko appointed economic development and trade minister of Ukraine, Kyiv Post (23 March 2012) Poroshenko explains reasons behind accepting economy minister's post, Kyiv Post (23 March 2012)
^Tigipko unanimously elected Regions Party deputy head, political council member, Kyiv Post (17 March 2012)
^Zlochevsky dismissed from post of Ecology and Natural Resources Minister, appointed Deputy Secretary of National Security and Defense Council, Kyiv Post (20 April 2012)
^(in Ukrainian) Prime-minister of Ukraine Mykola Yanovych Azarov introduced the Minister of Ecology and Natural Resources of Ukraine Eduard Stavytsky ("Прем'єр-міністр України Микола Янович АЗАРОВ представив Міністра екології та природних ресурсів України Едуарда СТАВИЦЬКОГО") Archived 2012-04-27 at the Wayback MachineMinistry's website (April 23, 2012)
^Baloha resigns as emergencies minister, Kyiv Post (2 November 2012)
^Azarov to tackle import of luxury goods to Ukraine, Kyiv Post (March 12, 2010)
^Ukraine's gross foreign debt reaches 93.5% of gross domestic product, Kyiv Post (March 17, 2010)
^Azarov says wages and pensions will be raised each quarter in 2013, Kyiv Post (13 April 2012)
^ a b c d e f g hNew coalition promises introduction of European standards of social protection, Kyiv Post (March 16, 2010)
^ a b cAzarov names main priorities of government's work, Kyiv Post (March 17, 2010)
^Azarov: Program on Ukraine's cooperation with international financial organizations is to be reviewed, Kyiv Post (March 11, 2010)
^ a b c d eUkraine's prime minister says budget problem hardest, Kyiv Post (March 11, 2010)
^ a b cAzarov: Fight against corruption is main task of executive branch, Kyiv Post (March 23, 2010)
^ a bAzarov: New government to focus on strengthening middle class in Ukraine, Kyiv Post (March 11, 2010)
^Tigipko: Ukraine planning to get at least Hr 10 billion from privatization, Kyiv Post (March 18, 2010)